Room for Murder Daily › Blog › 12 Thanksgiving Brain Teasers for Adults (with Answers)
12 Thanksgiving Brain Teasers for Adults (with Answers)
Twelve Thanksgiving brain teasers for adults, from quick table riddles to proper logic puzzles about pie thieves and broken gravy boats. Answers under every teaser, and a free printable PDF for the table.
- Twelve original Thanksgiving brain teasers: five quick ones, four medium logic puzzles and three hard ones.
- Answers are hidden under each teaser; the whole set prints as a free PDF with an answer key.
- Every logic teaser was checked by computer: exactly one answer each.
- Want a bigger puzzle for the table? Print the free Thanksgiving pack: six floor-plan murder mysteries with answers.
The turkey's in, the parade's on, and there's an hour before anyone is allowed near the pie. These twelve Thanksgiving brain teasers for adults fill it nicely: five quick ones you can read aloud, four logic puzzles for two heads together, and three properly devious ones for the people who solve the crossword in pen.
All twelve are original, the logic puzzles were checked by computer (each has exactly one answer), and the answers are hidden — tap Show the answer when you give up. Or print the lot:
Download the free printable PDFAll 12 puzzles on US Letter, with the answer key at the back
Quick Thanksgiving teasers (1–5)
Read one aloud between courses. A minute each, and no pencil needed.
1. The Turkey TimerEasy
Aunt Rosa’s 16-pound turkey needs 15 minutes per pound in the oven and then 30 minutes to rest before it’s carved. Dinner is at 5:00 p.m. sharp. What’s the latest the turkey can go in?
Show the answer
12:30 p.m. Sixteen pounds at fifteen minutes is 240 minutes — four hours — plus half an hour of resting: four and a half hours before five o’clock.
2. Double DiscountEasy
On Black Friday a coffee maker is marked 50% off, and the register takes another 50% off the sale price. Uncle Lou says that makes it free. Is he right?
Show the answer
No. Half of half is a quarter: you pay 25% of the original price. That’s 75% off, not 100%.
3. The Missing DrumstickEasy
Grandpa came back from the kitchen to find one of the turkey’s drumsticks gone. “All right — who took it?” Cousin Theo shrugged: “Don’t look at me. I can’t stand dark meat, and I’d never take the one nearest the window anyway.” Who took the drumstick?
Show the answer
Theo. Nobody had said which drumstick was missing — but Theo knew it was the one nearest the window.
4. The Mislabeled LeftoversEasy
Three containers of leftovers sit in the fridge, labelled STUFFING, CRANBERRY and MIXED. Your aunt mixed up the lids, so every label is now wrong. You’re allowed one spoonful from one container. Which one do you taste to relabel all three correctly?
Show the answer
The one labelled MIXED. Its label is wrong, so it holds only one thing — say stuffing. Then the container labelled CRANBERRY can’t be cranberry (wrong label) or stuffing (you just found it), so it’s the mixed one, and the one labelled STUFFING holds the cranberry sauce. (If your spoonful was cranberry, swap the two.)
5. Handshakes All RoundEasy
Ten relatives arrive for dinner, and every one of them shakes hands with every other relative exactly once. How many handshakes is that?
Show the answer
45. Each of the ten shakes nine hands, which makes 90 — but that counts every handshake twice (once for each person), so it’s 45.
Thanksgiving logic puzzles (6–9)
These need a minute of thought — or a napkin and a pen. Work in pairs: one reads the clues, the other keeps track.
6. The Pie ThiefMedium
Grandma’s pecan pie vanished from the windowsill, and one of four grandchildren took it. The thief lies; the other three tell the truth.
- June: “Lou took it.”
- Kip: “June is lying.”
- Lou: “Kip is telling the truth.”
- Mae: “I didn’t take it.”
Who took the pie?
Show the answer
June. If Kip were the thief, his lie would make June honest — and June says Lou did it, giving us two thieves. If Lou were the thief, his lie would make Kip a second liar. If Mae were the thief, honest June would be accusing the wrong person. Only June works: she lies about Lou, and Kip and Lou tell the truth.
7. Who Brought What?Medium
Abby, Ben, Carmen and Dev each brought one dish: pumpkin pie, green bean casserole, mashed potatoes or cranberry sauce.
- Abby brought neither a dessert nor anything made with potatoes.
- The cranberry sauce came from someone whose name has more than three letters.
- Ben brought the pie or the potatoes.
- Carmen’s dish was served last, after the main course.
Who brought the green bean casserole?
Show the answer
Dev. Carmen’s dish came after the main course, so she brought the pie, which leaves Ben the potatoes. The cranberry sauce came from Abby or Carmen (Ben and Dev only have three letters), and Carmen has the pie, so Abby brought the cranberry sauce — leaving the casserole for Dev.
8. The Seating ChartMedium
Five relatives sit on one side of the long table, in seats 1 to 5; seat 1 is nearest the kitchen.
- Grandma sits in seat 1.
- Ty sits right next to Grandma.
- Ray and Bev must not sit side by side (football).
- Jo sits closer to the kitchen than Bev.
Who’s in the seat at the far end?
Show the answer
Bev. Grandma and Ty take seats 1 and 2. Ray and Bev can’t be neighbours, so they take seats 3 and 5 with Jo between them in seat 4 — and since Jo is closer to the kitchen than Bev, Bev is in seat 5.
9. The Turkey TrotMedium
Five cousins ran the Thanksgiving morning Turkey Trot.
- Joan finished ahead of Hank.
- Kate crossed the line right after Lars.
- Iggy finished second or fourth.
- Hank wasn’t last, and Lars finished behind Hank.
Who won, and who came last?
Show the answer
Joan won and Kate came last. Joan, Hank, Lars and Kate must finish in that order, with Kate right behind Lars. If Iggy were fourth, he would split Lars and Kate, so Iggy was second: Joan, Iggy, Hank, Lars, Kate.
Room for Murder Daily
A new floor-plan murder mystery every morning: place the suspects, find who was alone with the victim. No sign-up, works on phones.
Play today's caseHard Thanksgiving brain teasers (10–12)
Three classic kinds of logic puzzle with a Thanksgiving twist: exactly one statement is false, two people are lying, and truth-tellers versus liars. The trick is always the same — assume, follow the consequences, and throw away any assumption that makes an honest person lie.
10. The Empty Whipped CreamHard
Someone emptied the can of whipped cream before the pie was even served. Exactly one of these three statements is false.
- Nell: “Otis did it.”
- Otis: “Pearl did it.”
- Pearl: “I didn’t do it.”
Who emptied the can?
Show the answer
Otis. Nell and Otis accuse different people, so one of them is wrong — and that’s the only false statement. So Pearl is telling the truth: she didn’t. Then Otis’s accusation is the false one, and Nell is right.
11. The Broken Gravy BoatHard
Grandma’s gravy boat is in pieces. Two cousins are lying — the one who broke it and the one covering for them. The other two tell the truth.
- Quinn: “Rosa didn’t break it.”
- Rosa: “Quinn broke it.”
- Sid: “Tess broke it.”
- Tess: “Rosa broke it.”
Who broke the gravy boat, and who’s covering?
Show the answer
Tess broke it; Rosa is covering. Rosa, Sid and Tess accuse three different people, so at most one of them is right: two of them are the liars, and Quinn is honest. So Rosa didn’t break it, which makes Tess a liar. If Sid were the other liar, Rosa would be honest and Quinn the breaker — but the breaker lies, and Quinn is honest. So Rosa is the other liar, Sid is honest, and Tess broke it.
12. Pilgrims and PrankstersHard
At the harvest fair, every stall-keeper is either an honest farmer, who always tells the truth, or a prankster, who always lies.
- Abner: “Exactly one of us three is honest.”
- Bea: “Abner and Cyrus are both pranksters.”
- Cyrus: “We’re all pranksters.”
Who’s honest?
Show the answer
Only Abner. An honest farmer would never call himself a prankster, so Cyrus is a prankster and his statement is false: somebody is honest. If Bea were honest, Abner would be a prankster and Bea the only honest one — which would make Abner’s statement true, impossible for a prankster. So Bea is a prankster too, and Abner is the one honest farmer, just as he says.
A bigger puzzle for the table: the free Thanksgiving pack
If the teasers went down well, try a full floor-plan murder mystery. Our free Thanksgiving logic puzzles pack has six cases from Cranberry Hollow — a pie night at the old inn, a train station, the town hall — each with a floor plan, a handful of suspects and one statement each. Place everyone (one person per row and column) and the killer is whoever was alone with the victim. Answers and step-by-step solutions are at the back, and it prints on US Letter or A4.
All of November, the free daily case on Room for Murder is set in the same town, so there's a new one every morning until the big day.
Thanksgiving puzzles to take home
Room for Murder: Thanksgiving
90 brand-new floor-plan murder mysteries in Cranberry Hollow — harvest suppers, bake sales and one very long Thanksgiving dinner. Every case is a two-page spread.
Solo or together · paperback or printable PDF
Paperback on Amazon PDF on Etsy
The Blue Ribbon Killer
Thanksgiving 1966 at an Iowa pie contest: 324 drawn pies, 13 clues and one poisoned slice.
1–4 solvers
See it on EtsyTips for puzzles at the Thanksgiving table
- Mix the teams. Pair a teenager with a grandparent — the logic puzzles reward patience as much as speed.
- Keep score with pie. First correct answer chooses their slice first.
- Read the answer out loud. Half the fun is the groan when the clue was right there in the story.
- Have a plan for the know-it-all. Hand them puzzle 12 first.
Questions people ask
What are good Thanksgiving brain teasers for adults?
Ones the whole table can argue about: logic puzzles where one cousin is lying, seating-chart puzzles, and quick riddles with a twist. The teasers on this page start easy (a turkey timer, a Black Friday discount) and finish with three proper logic puzzles that take five to ten minutes with a pencil.
Can kids do these Thanksgiving brain teasers?
Teasers 1–5 work for most kids from about nine, and 6–9 for confident readers from about eleven with a little help. The last three are for teens and adults — or for a kid-and-grown-up team.
How do I use brain teasers at Thanksgiving dinner?
Print the free PDF and put a page at every few places, or read one aloud between courses and give a slice of pie to the first correct answer. The logic puzzles work well in teams of two.
Do you have more Thanksgiving puzzles?
Yes: a free printable pack of six Thanksgiving murder mysteries on our Thanksgiving logic puzzles page, a new free Cranberry Hollow case every day in November, and the Room for Murder: Thanksgiving book with 90 more.
Keep reading
- 12 Christmas Brain Teasers for Adults (with Answers)
- 25 Murder Mystery Riddles with Answers (Short Whodunits for Adults)
- Knights and Knaves Puzzles with Answers — and the Murder Mystery Version
We make the games mentioned in this guide — that's why we know them well. Links to Etsy go to our own shop, Midnight Motive.